If you’re looking for glamorous model shots, this isn’t the month for you. October did, however, feature some surprising celebrity hits (Reese Witherspoon in a pimp coat!). Unfortunately, the hits are stacked against a longer list of flops. From Vogue‘s Rooney Mara cover to Jennifer Aniston on Harper’s Bazaar, there were a staggering number of images that left us wondering if they were actually outtakes. Here’s a look at all the October 2017 magazine covers you need to know about.